|
Dole and Honduran union sign "peace agreement" |
|
9th August 2010, Banana Link
The Standard Fruit Company and the SUTRASFCO union, after some 20 meetings in recent months, have signed a historic agreement that brings to an end the controversy over the restructuring of the Dole operation in the Aguan Valley of Northern Honduras. The agreement was signed on 5th August in the presence of Labour Minister, Felícito Avila, at a ceremony in Tegucigalpa.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Supermarket suppliers get new adjudicator for disputes |
|
3rd August 2010, BBC
An adjudicator to resolve disputes between supermarkets and their suppliers is to be established under plans announced by the government. The Groceries Code Adjudicator (GCA) will sit within the Office of Fair Trading (OFT), but will be independent, the government said. It will investigate complaints from UK and overseas suppliers about the way they are treated by supermarkets. But retailers argue that shoppers will end up paying for the new body.
The move follows a recommendation from the Competition Commission in 2008. Following a long-running investigation into the grocery market, it argued that the power of the large supermarkets was having an adverse impact on suppliers and consumers.
The government hopes to have set up the GCA within the next 18 months to two years, the Department for Business, Innovation and Skills told the BBC.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
US government acts on Guatemalan labour rights violations |
|
30th July 2010, Banana Link
Over two years after Guatemalan and US trade unions filed the very first complaint under the terms of the Free Trade Agreement between the USA and Central America/Dominican Republic (CAFTA-DR) over systematic violations of labour laws in Guatemala, the United States government has concluded that "the Government is failing to meet its obligations" to effectively enforce its own laws on the freedom of association, the right to collective bargaining and acceptable conditions of work. The US Trade Representative also noted that "the issue of labour-related violence is a matter of serious concern". If, after 90 days of talks between the governments, satisfactory remedial actions are not agreed, the US could impose fines of up to US $15 million per year. This money would go into a fund to finance initiatives to improve the enforcement of labour standards.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Dominican Republic set to become largest ACP banana exporter |
|
26th July 2010, Valverde; Banana Link
The Dominican Republic is set to overtake Cameroon as the ACP group's largest banana exporter. In the second quarter of this year, the Caribbean nation exported almost twice the volume exported from Cameroon. Producers' association Adobanano predicts that in 2010 the country's exports will exceed 300,000 tonnes for the first time.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Dole workers accept reduced redundancy package |
|
25th July 2010, La Ceiba, Honduras; Banana Link
Negotiations between Dole's Honduran subsidiary and trade union SUTRASFCO finally concluded in La Ceiba with a deal that will limit the damage of the company's original threat to close down a large group of plantations.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Severe anti-union repression in Panama |
13th July 2010, Banana Link
Banana Link joins the ITUC in condemning the violent repression of the recent workers strike in the Bocas del Toro Province that has resulted in killings, more than 100 people being injured and at least 300 arrests.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Honduras: Violence and human rights violations escalate |
|
16th June 2010, Brussels; ITUC
Honduras is immersed in a very worrying spiral of violence, and the international trade union movement remains on the alert for human rights violations. Being a trade unionist or part of the Resistance Front implies major risks in the Honduras of today. Various trade union and community leaders have faced death threats and attempts on their lives over recent weeks.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Guatemala Update: Desperation in Izabal as new floods wreak more havoc |
|
13th June 2010, Morales, Guatemala; Banana Link
Just as thousands of banana workers and their families were beginning to recover from the devastation of hurricane-force winds and Tropical Storm Agatha, the river Motagua again burst its banks in the early hours of the morning of Saturday 12th June.
Workers had reoccupied their homes and were in the process of cleaning up and retrieving whatever belongings had not been destroyed by the first floods, when an alert came to evacuate their houses again. The whole of the Yuma plantation and parts of the Choctaw and Chickasaw plantations were flooded again as workers sought emergency refuge in El Cedro village.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Costa Rica hauled over the coals at ILO |
|
9th June 2010, Geneva, Banana Link
Costa Rica is once again charged by workers' organisations as well as some governments and employers at this year's 99th International Labour Conference in Geneva, of being in systematic violation of core international labour standards. In an intervention on behalf of the British Trades Union Congress, the AFL-CIO of the USA and other European trade unions, the British workers' representative pointed out how the Costa Rican government has proved highly resistant to the repeated requests from the ILO to supply more information about the action it is taking to:
- Bring its law into compliance with core ILO conventions, and in the case of this latest report, specifically with Convention 98;
- Inform the ILO and others how the justice system is changing to speed up the processing of legal cases brought by trade unionists and workers for unfair dismissal;
- Demonstrate how policies such as the fostering of non-union ‘direct settlements’ and the so called `solidarismo’ system is not directly undermining real trade unions.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
URGENT APPEAL for Guatemalan banana worker families hit by devastation |
June 2010, Banana Link
Guatemala was already in an official "State of Calamity" following the eruption of the Pacaya Volcano, which did widespread damage to plantations on the Pacific coastal plain. In the last week of May, hurricane-force winds destroyed swathes of plantations in the Caribbean coastal area. Then on 30th May, Tropical Storm Agatha and its intense rains caused rivers in Izabal, the Pacific coastal region and along the border with El Salvador to burst their banks. 152 people have been killed, 54 are missing and 59 injured. Some 110,000 people were reported to still be at risk.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Del Monte commits to rehabilitate Izabal plantations |
|
3rd June 2010, Banana Link
[Right: Maria del Rosario Ramirez who works at the Chicksaw packhouse, standing amidst flood damage.]
Despite the very considerable damage done to its plantations, Bandegua, the Guatemalan subsidiary of Fresh Del Monte, has told the trade union SITRABI that it will not abandon production in Izabal.
Early reports suggest that at least one quarter of Guatemalan banana exports have been damaged by three natural phenomena in the last week or so: the ash from the eruption of Pacaya, hurricane-force winds in Izabal, then Tropical Storm Agatha. It is estimated that 50% of Pacific coast banana plantations are lost.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
New banana tariffs in force |
31st May 2010, Geneva, Banana Link
The Geneva Agreement on Trade in Bananas, reached last December after years of trade disputes, was formally signed at the World Trade Organisation in Geneva today. The signatory countries are: Brazil, Colombia, Costa Rica, Ecuador, Guatemala, Honduras, Mexico, Nicaragua, Panama, Peru and Venezuela. The European Union has agreed to reduce its banana import tariff on these so-called 'third country' (non-ACP) bananas from 176 euros/tonne to 114 euros/tonne by 1st January 2017. If there is no comprehensive Doha Round agreement in the WTO by the end of 2013, then the step-by-step reduction will take two years longer.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Guatemalan plantations devastated |
|
31st May 2010, Morales, Izabal, Banana Link
Guatemala was already in an official "State of Calamity" following the eruption late last week of the Pacaya Volcano. Anibal Archila, a journalist well-known to social organisations was killed in the eruption and there was substantial material damage. Then, this weekend, Tropical Storm Agatha and its intense rains have caused rivers in Izabal, the Pacific coastal region and along the border with El Salvador to burst their banks. Over 90 people have been killed, 54 are missing and 59 injured. Some 110,000 people are reported still to be at risk.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
The bitter taste of another price war... |
|
25th May 2010, Banana Link Press Release
Yet again the leading British supermarkets are making plantation workers in Latin America bear the cost of slashing fruit prices in this country. Pineapples are now being sold for as little as 50p according to a report by leading trade magazine The Grocer. This is one third less than was being charged last year. As the price wars pursued in bananas have shown, low prices here have a high cost for workers and their communities in producer countries such as Costa Rica, including poverty wages and environmental devastation.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Colombian oilpalm workers' leader killed |
|
24th May 2010
Just a few weeks after announcing that violence had been averted at the Palo Alto oilpalm plantation in Northern Colombia, Francisco Antonio Abello was assassinated on 17th May. He was one of the 185 workers who led the strike movement at the beginning of the year that resulted in the recognition of the SINTRAINAGRO union and an agreement with the company. The company had threatened to respond to the industrial action with violence at the time, but the trade union movement had appealed to the authorities to ensure that workers were allowed to continue their legitimate protest in peace. However, this had not succeeded in stopping the threats, which were finally carried out.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Dole accepts reduction in Honduran job losses |
|
24th May 2010, Banana Link
The Standard Fruit Company of Honduras, subsidiary of the world's leading fruit company, has now proposed to reduce the number of job losses in the Coyoles Central district. This will still have a very serious impact on the local economy, but is less than the 2300 initially rumoured to be under the axe.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Evidence of unfair buyer power practices by EU |
|
24th May 2010, AAI
In March 2009, The Abuse of Supermarket Buyer Power in the EU Food Retail Sector: Preliminary Survey of Evidence was submitted to the European Parliament. The report provided preliminary evidence, gathered across 27 EU Member States, of unfair or abusive practices by supermarkets, primarily through the exercise of buyer power, against food suppliers. It also commented on the ways in which supermarket buyer power is reinforced by the rise of private label goods and buying alliances, and it considered the impacts of supermarket conduct on independent wholesalers and retailers.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
French government role in regulating fair trade |
|
12th May 2010, Banana Link
The establishment of the National Fair Trade Commission (CNCE) under the aegis of the Economics and Sustainable Development Ministries is the first move by a national government to become involved in regulating fair trade. Its key mission is to "make the information provided to the public clearer". It will also be a "body for exchange and information that will work to promote fair trade to consumers, local authorities and companies". The main fair trade organisations in France also participate in the Commission.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Costa Rica: Police called to break up union meeting |
7th May 2010, Cariari
On two occasions last week, police were called by the management of the Bonanza Campo 5 plantation near Cariari in Costa Rica to throw a trade union official off the plantation. On the second occasion the police were called during a meeting between the official and a group of workers on the public highway.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Union finds company's offer unacceptable |
6th May 2010, Olanchito
The proposal made on Monday 3rd May by the Dole subsidiary, Standard Fruit Company of Honduras, to its workers in the Lower Aguan Valley, has been rejected by the SUTRASFCO union leadership. However, the union has promised to consult its members over the company's proposal to close nine 'service centres' in the Coyoles Central district. This would mean 800 redundancies of permanent workers plus a further 1,000 temporary workers whose contracts would not be renewed, reported José Alfredo Jiménez, union president. The company wants to lay people off as soon as possible, at least by the end of May, it appears.
The local Labour Secretary, representing the government, has offered to host meetings between the two parties in order to try and minimise the loss of jobs.
Source: La Prensa, Honduras
|
|
|
German retailer Lidl retracts false claims on fair working conditions |
4th May 2010, CCC Germany and Banana Link
Consumer and worker rights organisations are celebrating a historic victory after the giant German retailer Lidl agreed to withdraw public claims that its goods were being produced under fair and decent working conditions. The agreement was reached following a legal challenge, launched by the Consumer Agency Hamburg, which accused Lidl of engaging in false advertising.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Honduras: Agreement to avoid closure |
|
20th April, Banana Link
After a meeting between Standard Fruit and the SUTRASFCO union yesterday, in the presence of Honduran Labour Ministry officials, it has emerged that the company is prepared to explore options not to close the thirteen plantations in Coyoles Central that it had said earlier this month it would have to close. Standard Fruit has promised the union that it will put a restructuring proposal on the table by 3rd May. However, it is clear that the union will be under pressure to make concessions and to accept flexibility over some clauses of the collective bargaining agreement with Standard.
Source: La Prensa, Honduras
|
|
|
Unionised Dole plantations close |
|
19th April 2010, Banana Link
Standard Fruit, the Dole subsidiary that has operated in Honduras since the beginning of the 20th century, has announced that it is closing down thirteen of its banana plantations in Coyoles Central in the Aguan valley in Northern Honduras. SUTRASFCO, the trade union that represents the Standard Fruit workers and has a collective agereement with the company, alleges that the company is making 2,500 of their members redundant and replacing them with non-union workers as a way of reducing costs and breaking the union. In the company's statement to the press, it noted that it is cheaper to produce in Guatemala at "no social cost". Honduras is the only country in which there is a union and collective bargaining on Dole plantations.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
14th April 2010, Banana Link
In the film BANANAS!*, twelve Nicaraguan banana plantation workers are suing Dole for concealing the dangers of a pesticide that they claim made them sterile.
For more information about the use of Nemagon, the film itself and
Dole's response to it please visit the Bananas!* website
here .
This controversial film is being shown in London for the first time this
week at the ICA. Visit Facebook
for more details of the showings.
Sources: Bananas!* The Movie
|
|
|
Banana union leader assassinated |
|
7th April 2010, ITUC OnLine
The ITUC joins with the United Trade Union Confederation of Guatemala (CUSG), the General Workers’ Centre of Guatemala (CGTG) and the Workers’ Trade Union of Guatemala (UNSITRAGUA) in condemning in the strongest possible terms the assassinations on 6th and 26th March of Luis Felipe Cho and Samuel Ramírez Paredes.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Agreement brings successful end to strike at Palo Alto plantation, Colombia |
|
7th April 2010, Banana Link
An agreement has been reached between Palo Alto Gnecco Espinosa Investments and SINTRAINAGRO, the agricultural workers’ union in Colombia, bringing an end to a 67-day strike at a plantation in Ciénaga district, Magdalena. The Ministry of Social Protection will act as guarantor of the agreement. Prior to the deal the company had been operating a hard-line policy of refusing to recognise workers’ rights to free association. The strike had been initiated in response to the illegal and violent dismissal of 185 out of 200 workers back in January when workers decided to join the trade union.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
ACP-EU produces Declaration on Bananas |
|
6th April 2010, Banana Link
The WTO banana deal, agreed in December 2009, was a subject of discussion at the session of the ACP-EU Joint Parliamentary Assembly which met last week in Tenerife. As a result, the Assembly issued a Declaration which first outlines the deal and its impact before setting out ten demands relating to the banana trade. These demands include enlarging the financial package to ACP and European banana producers to help them adjust to the new trade regime; and a request that EU nations increase their efforts to prevent the import of bananas from countries and exporters with inadequate policies on tax evasion, corruption, labour standards and human rights violations.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
EU announces €190 million support package for ACP countries |
|
25th March 2010, Banana Link
On Wednesday 17th March, the European Commission announced its adoption of a €190 million support package for banana exporters in African, Caribbean and Pacific (ACP) countries. This comes as part of the historic Agreement on Trade in Bananas which was finalised in Geneva in December 2009. The Agreement commits the EU to reducing its import tariff on Latin American bananas from €176 to €114 per tonne by 2016, thereby eroding the preferential treatment that the EU has given to ACP banana exporters in recent decades. Andrís Piebalgs, European Commissioner for Development, stated that “These measures will help ACP countries to adapt to the new realities of the banana trade regime. The Commission has committed itself to fully stand by ACP countries to foster their efficient integration into the world economy while respecting international trade rules. This package delivers on that commitment.”
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
GMB protest at Westminster Cathedral |
|
18th February 2010, GMB
GMB, in support of banana workers union SITRAP in Costa Rica, is launching a major UK campaign to secure an end to the Pope John XXIII School in the capital San Jose being used to promote the anti-trade union strategies of the employers in Costa Rica’s tropical fruit plantations. This centre was established by the Catholic diocese of San Jose in 1963 and its union busting activities are a relic of the Cold War.
To launch the campaign GMB union activists will stage a demonstration:
11am Tuesday 23rd February 2010
Cathedral Piazza, Westminster Cathedral, Victoria Street, London SW1P 1QW
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Black Sigatoka found in St Lucia |
9th February 2010, Reefertrends and Banana Link
Agriculture officials have confirmed that the banana industry has lost the battle to prevent the arrival and spread of the fungal disease.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Taking the World Banana Forum forwards |
|
2nd February 2010, Banana Link
On 8th December 2009 at the FAO headquarters in Rome, the World Banana Forum was launched, creating a permanent space of assembly for participants representing the global banana supply-chain. All 150 participants agreed to set the mission of ‘Working Together for Sustainable Banana Production and Trade’. As such, the aim of the Forum is to promote open dialogue and inspire collaboration between stakeholders in order to produce pragmatic outcomes for the improvement of the banana industry and to achieve an industry-wide consensus on best practices regarding workplace issues, gender equity, environmental impact, sustainable production and economic issues.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
The Philippines: Mindanao farmers kick off protests |
|
12th January, Banana Link
Farmer leaders in Northern Mindanao yesterday marked the start of Lakbayan, a series of protests in major cities nationwide, by marching with torches. Lakbayan commemorates the Mendiola massacre in 1987, and protests will continue until 22nd January.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
185 plantation workers sacked for joining a trade union |
|
14th January 2010, SINTRAINAGRO, Ciénaga, Magdalena
185 workers at the Palo Alto plantation, belonging to Palo Alto Gnecco Espinosa Investments, in the Ciénaga district of Magdalena province, were evicted from their workplace at gun-point, leaving one of the workers injured.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Government to set up supermarket ombudsman |
|
14th January, Tescopoly
The Government has announced today that it will accept the Competition Commission's recommendation to establish a new supermarket ombudsman to enforce the new supermarket code of practice and protect suppliers from abuses of power by the big retailers.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Producers in El Oro province sell more than 42 thousand bunches of bananas to the Government |
|
7th January 2010, El Comercio, Ecuador
Within the last six days, producers in the province of El Oro have received $121,000 for the bunches delivered. The purchasing system for bunches of bananas that the Government has pursued since 31st December has not convinced many producers in El Oro. Yesterday, in the Council of El Oro (la Gobernación), no agreement was reached to increase the price. Representatives of 10 banana producer organizations tried to persuade
the authority to be paid between $4 and $5 per bunch. This would help
to finance the labour costs for the handling, cutting, washing and
transportation of the fruit.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
EU, Latin Americans Call Truce in Long-Running Banana War |
|
16th Dec, Bridges Weekly Trade News
The European Union and a group of Latin American countries have reached an agreement to end tensions over the EU’s tariffs on banana imports, bringing to a close the longest international trade dispute in memory.
At issue is the EU’s current banana import regime, which allows 775,000 tonnes of the fruit from African, Caribbean and Pacific (ACP) countries - many of which are former European colonies - to enter the bloc duty-free each year. Meanwhile, Brussels places a €176 per tonne tariff on bananas from all other exporters.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Historic agreement reached over EU import tariffs |
|
15th December, Banana Link
After decades of dispute, the world’s ‘banana wars’ are finally set to come to an end. An historic deal between the EU, Latin America, African-Caribbean-Pacific (ACP) countries and the US was signed at the weekly meeting of the WTO Council Secretariat in Geneva this afternoon, after the last details were agreed yesterday. Trade negotiators cheered and applauded as Eckart Guth, the EU ambassador to the WTO, announced, "So, it's done. Thank you very much". European Trade Commissioner Benita Ferrero-Waldner expressed her relief that the dispute had finally been settled: "I'm very happy to see the longest-running trade dispute finally solved," she said. "History is being made today because this dispute has soured global trade relations for too long." The deal signifies a step towards an eventual agreement in the WTO’s Doha Round of trade negotiations which aim to reduce barriers to global trade.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Launch of the World Banana Forum – 7-8 December 2009, Rome, Italy |
|
2nd December, Banana Link
Stakeholders in the banana industry are to launch the World Banana Forum on sustainable banana production and trade at the headquarters of the Food and Agriculture Organisation of the United Nations (FAO) in Rome, Italy next week. This meeting is the result of years of previous collaborative work involving representatives from banana industry – civil society organisations, fruit companies, retailers and national governments - as part of the ‘Multi-Stakeholder Forum Project’. This project has been coordinated with support from Banana Link and is implemented by the FAO with co-funding from the Department for International Development (DfID) of the United Kingdom.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Agreement is "near, but not yet in the bag" |
19th November, Banana Link
A spokesman for the European Commission's Trade Directorate told the Spanish media yesterday that an agreement is "near, but not yet in the bag". It would seem that only certain legal aspects remain to be resolved. The deal also concerns duties on other tropical products like pineapples. Observers note that it could give a boost to seriously flagging world trade talks.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
WTO banana deal expected this week |
11th November 2009, Banana Link
Trade officials have been meeting intensively for the last two weeks in an ongoing effort to finalise a deal to conclude a long-running dispute over banana tariffs at the WTO. Officials say they hope to conclude the talks ahead of the WTO’s ministerial conference, which is set to begin on 30 November, and an announcement outlining the framework of the potential deal is expected this week.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Guatemalan women workers locked in Labour Ministry |
6th November 2009, Banana Link
Nineteen women plantation workers' leaders who travelled to Guatemala City to hold a press conference denouncing abuses of workers' rights in the farms where they work were locked in and subjected to intimidation by Labour Ministry officials today.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Taking a stand against banana price wars |
|
2nd November 2009, Banana Link
An independent retailer has decided to take a stand against the banana price wars that have afflicted the UK banana market since September. The savage price cuts were initiated by Asda/WalMart and Aldi. Many growers and plantation workers fear that, despite reassurances from the retailers, the retail price wars will have dire consequences for prices and wages at the beginning of the banana chain.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Ecuadorian president proposes state export company |
|
October 26th 2009, Banana Link
The world's biggest banana exporter has started the process of setting up a state banana exporting company. In his weekly broadcast to the media, President Rafael Correa said he was fed up with the abuses by companies in the sector who underpay producers and avoid taxes: "The definitive solution is to create a state marketing company and we are already in the process of doing so".
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Costa Rica Legislators Heading for Confrontation with ILO |
19th October 2009, Banana Link
It was in September 2006 that trade unions first lodged a complaint with the European Union about systematic violations of trade union rights and the right to free collective bargaining in the Costa Rican private and public sectors. The unions asked for an inquiry into whether the country should continue to benefit from trade preferences granted for countries that abide by a series of international labour, human rights and environmental standards. A second complaint was lodged by the Costa Rican confederation CSJMP when trade preferences offered by the EU were up for renewal at the end of 2008.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Honduran worker to be reinstated |
|
13th October 2009, Banana Link
Thanks to all those who responded to the appeal from Honduran unions, the company offered to negotiate at the end of September over the case of Emelina Vasquez. She was fired in January 2007 after being sexually assaulted by a superviser in the plantation where she worked.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Another fish-kill in Costa Rica |
6th October, Banana Link
On 6th October, a chemical discharge provoked a mass fish-kill in the canal of Gochen in the Limón province of Costa Rica. This channel has been contaminated half a dozen times in the last 8 years, but the authorities have never found the guilty party. The SITRAP Union has made an international appeal for help in reporting that environmental damage continues to go unpunished in Costa Rica.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Concern mounts over future of Windward bananas |
|
12th October 2009, WINFA Media, Banana Link
Fairtrade supporters, campaigners and consumers last Saturday expressed their continued support for banana farmers in the Windward Islands amidst the great difficulties facing them at present. Over the past year, hundreds of Fairtrade banana farmers from Dominica, St.Vincent and St.Lucia have been forced out of the extra-regional export market for a variety of reasons. These include low returns to farmers and problems with certification to meet British supermarket standards.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Aldi takes banana price wars to scandalous new low |
8th October 2009, Banana Link
This morning the German supermarket giant has plunged banana prices to another historical low by selling a kilo for 39p. Given that Aldi is seen as the price-setter for bananas across the European Union, the move threatens to spread the price wars to other parts of the continent.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Retailers declare war on banana workers |
|
7th October 2009, World Decent Work Day, Banana Link
Once again Asda/WalMart has led a round of savage banana price cuts in its UK stores, seemingly regardless of the consequences. Retail prices have come down from 99p at the end of 2008 to 46p per kilo today. The latest salvo in the price wars of Britain's biggest volume food product started in late September with Asda cutting to 57p/kg. This was immediately followed by Tesco, Morrison and Sainsbury, who together account for three quarters of all bananas sold in the country. German discounters Aldi and Lidl went even lower - to 55p/kg - and Lidl followed the big four down again to 46p/kg.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Decent work starts with real trade union freedom...but Dole continues resisting changes in practice |
|
New report released on 7th October 2009, World Day for Decent Work
7th October 2009, Banana Link
In the last three years, since the publication of the 'Dole: Behind the Smoke-Screen' report by a coalition of civil society organisations, the fruit multinational has met on various occasions with trade union organisations in Costa Rica, Ecuador and Peru. The new report published today, on the World Day for Decent Work, by the same organisations notes that Dole has shown a certain openness to dialogue on the issues of trade union freedom and collective bargaining in those countries.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Another Costa Rican pineapple plantation closed down |
|
23rd September 2009, Banana Link
The Sebastopol pineapple company in the Guacimo canton of Costa Rica's Limon Province was obliged to close on 22nd September because it had failed to comply with an order to treat its waste pineapples. The waste residues from pineapple production attract a blood-sucking fly which reproduces prolifically and infests neighbouring cattle farms. The flies suck the blood of cattle causing them to lose up to a kilogram in weight per day.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Costa Rica: "Dirty tactics" put new labour legislation in danger |
|
September 4th, Banana Link
For over a decade, successive Costa Rican governments have been under pressure from repeated recommendations by the International Labour Organisation (ILO) to tighten up legislation to ensure that the freedom for workers to join or form trade unions is respected in practice. Earlier this year a package of measures promised by President Arias to the ILO over two years ago was finally presented to the Costa Rican Parliament. The "Trade Union Freedoms" Bill (Draft Law 13475) is scheduled to be voted one way or the other this month. The measures in the draft Bill include:
- easier registration requirements for new trade unions;
- protection against unfair dismissal for private sector workers who join a trade union;
- a reduction in the percentage of (permanent) workers who are union members in any one workplace required to trigger collective bargaining from 50%+1 to 30%.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Light at the end of tunnel for tariff negotiations |
|
8th September 2009, Expreso, Guayaquil
After more than 15 years of conflict over the European Union's banana import policies, it seems that the parties may be entering the home straight towards a lasting settlement of the dispute when they meet in Geneva on 17th September.
Following a series of meetings initiated by the Ecuadorian government, Costa Rica, Panama, Guatemala, Nicaragua and Peru have agreed to join Ecuador in presenting a united front to the European Union negotiators. According to Ecuador's Deputy Trade Minister, Julio Oleas, these countries have instructed their ambassadors in Geneva to take the same position as Ecuador when negotiations reconvene next week.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Philippines: aerial spraying battle challenges expansion |
27th August 2009, Banana Link
Just weeks after the industry announced that banana exports were set to increase by another 15% this year because of booming demand in Japan, the Philippine Department of Environment and Natural Resources has ordered the suspension of aerial spraying of fungicides in banana plantations around the city of Davao.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Mozambique's Model Banana Investment? |
|
20th August 2009, Banana Link
In early 2008, Chiquita announced two new joint ventures to produce and export bananas from Southern Africa: one in Angola, the other in Mozambique. The most advanced of the two projects is in Mozambique's Northern province of Nampula, from where the company this week announced that it will start exporting 50 containers a week to Europe and the Middle East in December 2009.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Peruvian Workers Host Tenth COLSIBA Conference |
|
19th August 2009, Banana Link
COLSIBA, the Coordinating Body of Latin American Banana and Agro-industrial Workers Unions, held their 10th delegate conference from 4th to 8th August. The conference was hosted by COLSIBA’s newest affiliate, SITAG-Peru, who represent agricultural workers in the banana, mango and sugarcane sectors in Northern Peru.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
International Day of Solidarity with Honduras |
11th August 2009, ITUC Online
More than one month after the coup in Honduras the prospects of a negotiated settlement of the crisis are sadly fading and the repression and violence have been continuing, with severe restrictions on freedom of association and expression and harassment and harsh repression of all forms of demonstration against the de facto government.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Chiquita in Latin America |
|
29 July 2009, www.counterpunch.org
When the Honduran military overthrew the democratically elected government of Manuel Zelaya two weeks ago there might have been a sigh of relief in the corporate board rooms of Chiquita banana. Earlier this year the Cincinnati-based fruit company joined Dole in criticizing the government in Tegucigalpa which had raised the minimum wage by 60%. Chiquita complained that the new regulations would cut into company profits, requiring the firm to spend more on costs than in Costa Rica: 20 cents more to produce a crate of pineapple and ten cents more to produce a crate of bananas to be exact. In all, Chiquita fretted that it would lose millions under Zelaya’s labor reforms since the company produced around 8 million crates of pineapple and 22 million crates of bananas per year.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Fired Belizean banana workers win historic court case |
|
29 July 2009, Banana Link
Six banana workers who were fired from their jobs in 2001 have won a historic court case against union busting on a Fyfees supplier farm called Maya King. Justice Samuel Awich ruled that when their employer John Zabaneh fired them it was in direct contravention of the Trade Union and Employers Organization’s Recognition and Registration Act. The workers who were employed by Zabaneh’s Maya King Farms alleged that their terminations in May of 2001 were as a result of their efforts to form a union.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Honduran trade unionists arrested |
|
14 July 2009, Banana Link
On the afternoon of July 2nd the Honduran trade union activist and COSIBAH (Coordination of Honduran Banana and Agro-Industrial Workers) representative, Iris Munguia, was arrested along with many others whilst participating in a protest demanding the return of the elected president, Manuel Zelaya Rosales.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Dole hopes to overturn $2 billion in pesticide rulings |
24 June 2009, The Packer
Reacting to a recent ruling by a Los Angeles superior court judge,Westlake Village, Calif.-based Dole Food Co. Inc. hopes to reverse $2 billion in verdicts against it and other U.S. companies for pesticide poisoning.
On June 17, superior court judge Victoria Chaney dismissed with prejudice two lawsuits against Dole by Nicaraguan laborers claiming that the pesticide dibromochloropropane, or DBCP, made them sterile while working on Dole-contracted banana farms in the 1970s.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Del Monte ignores pineapple contamination order. |
04 June 2009, www.reefertrends.com
Trade Union SITRAP has accused Fresh Del Monte of ignoring an order from Costa Rica’s Environment Tribunal to close down one of its pineapple operations.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Tela Railroad Co suffers earthquake damage |
04 June 2009, http://www.reefertrends.com
While Dole’s Honduran subsidiary appears to have escaped largely unscathed by last week’s earthquake the Chiquita subsidiary has fared a lot worse.
The major problem faced by the Tela Railroad Co is the damage done to the dykes or levees that run alongside watercourses protecting the banana plantations from flooding. With the rainy season less than two months away President of Union Sitraterco is warning that unless these levees are rebuilt there will be ‘incalculable damage’ to the country’s banana production as well as communities that depend on the industry for employment. Other infrastructure such as bridges, roads and irrigation channels have also been affected.
|
|
|
'Latin America remains the deadliest continent for trade unionists with over 66 murdered in 2008' |
|
ITUC, June 2009
Worldwide in 2008, at least 76 labour activists were killed as a result of their actions for workers’ rights. Latin America remains the deadliest continent for trade unionists with over 66 murdered in 2008. 49 Colombian trade unionists lost their lives (including 16 union leaders, 4 of whom were women), a 25% increase over 2007. Trade unionists were also killed in Guatemala (9), Honduras (3) and Venezuela (4) among others.
Read the 2009 Annual Survey of violations of trade union rights published by the International Trade Union Confederation (ITUC).
Visit our Guatemala campaign page to learn more about the situation in the banana sector.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
PAN AP Hits Croplife on Aerial Pesticide Spraying in Davao del Sur's Banana Plantations |
|
10 June 2009, Pesticide Action Network Asia and the Pacific
Pesticide Action Network Asia and the Pacific (PAN AP), an international group working towards the reduction and elimination of pesticides, criticized Croplife and the Philippine Banana Growers and Exporters Association (PBGEA) for reacting negatively to a Department of Health (DOH) study and claiming that pesticides are safe to use.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
ACP states seek 500 million euros in EU banana deal |
2 June 2009, www.caribbeannetnews.com
BRUSSELS, Belgium (Reuters) -- African, Caribbean and Pacific (ACP) top banana export countries sought on Friday 500 million euros ($694 million) in compensation from the European Union as part of a deal to end the world's longest-running trade dispute.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
The Man from Del Monte says “No” to environmental ruling |
2 June 2009, Banana Link
The residents of the Milano community in the canton of Siquirres in Costa Rica blocked the main arterial road from the capital, San Jose to the main port, Limon where it passes through the area for seven hours on 21st May 2009. They have been protesting for over two years about contamination of their water and land by nearby plantations that produce Del Monte Gold brand pineapples.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Victory for SINTRAINAGRO. |
27 May 2009, Banana Link
The strike led by the Colombian Union SINTRAINAGRO has ended successfully for the workers. The Union has achieved all the objectives that they demanded during the negotiations, such as salary increases and an end to the subcontracting of workers in several jobs. In the SINTRAINAGRO’s communique (in Spanish) they acknowledge the international solidarity they have received through the IUF that they believe has strengthened them as a union.
For further information in Spanish click here.
|
|
|
Unrelenting Violence and Impunity in Guatemala |
18 May 2009, ITUC Online
The ITUC has strongly condemned and denounced the ever-worsening climate of impunity in Guatemala, highlighted once again by the assassination on 10 May of lawyer Rodrigo Rosenberg, who had left a video accusing President Colom in the event of his murder.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Impunity and corruption in Guatemala |
|
13 May 2009, Banana Link
The Guatemalan union, UNSITRAGUA has submitted an appeal to the Supreme Court in response to the reversal of a labour court judge’s decision in 2008 which ordered the reinstatement of the workers of Olga Maria. Olga Maria is a company that supplies Chiquita Brands.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
DBCP victims' lawyers found guilty of fraud! |
6 May 2009, Banana Link
“The court became deeply concerned that fraud may be occurring and that it has tentacles that extend to all of the Nicaraguan (pesticide) cases pending before it," wrote Los Angeles County Judge Victoria G. Chaney in court documents after a hearing in late March. On 23rd April, she threw out two cases against Dole Food Company and Dow Chemical brought by US-based lawyer Juan Dominguez and a Nicaraguan colleague finding the prosecution lawyers on behalf of Nicaraguan victims guilty of fraud, conspiracy and denial of due process to the defending companies."What occurred here is not just fraud on the court but blatant extortion of defendants," declared Superior Court Judge Victoria G. Chaney. "I cannot in good conscience allow this case to continue."
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Pineapple trade hits new heights |
20 April 2009, www.reefertrends.com
Although Japanese imports dip to a level last seen in 2004, EU and US pineapple imports rise for an eighth successive year.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Colombia faces banana strike |
|
17 April 2009, www.refertrends.com
Union Sintrainagro has called for an indefinite strike starting next week following
the failure of negotiations over a reform of working practices.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
March 2009, Bridges
European and Latin American negotiators appear to be nearing a conclusion to the WTO’s longest-running dispute, unofficial sources from both sides say.
In February, the EU reportedly offered to lower its most-favoured-nation banana tariff from -176 per metric tonne to -114 per tonne by 2019. This is three years later than was envisaged in the compromise reached during the WTO ‘mini-ministerial’ in July 2008. When that meeting collapsed, the EU took the deal off the table, insisting it was contingent on a successful conclusion of Doha Round negotiating modalities.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Norwegian government pushes for global framework agreements |
February 2008, TUC International Bulletin
In a recent white paper on Corporate Social Responsibility, the Government of Norway pushes for more companies to enter into global framework agreements with the trade union movement. The Government asks that Norwegian companies actively work in favour of global framework agreements, based on the ILO core conventions and contributes to strengthening workers' rights. It also states that companies should considering ways of establishing some sort of system that could ensure that the voice of workers are heard in the workplaces in those countries that do not have freedom of organizing and of collective bargaining. 'The responsibility of policy makers and the business sector to ensure decent working conditions does not stop at the Norwegian border' the Foreign Minister Mr. Jonas Gahr Støre said in his comment.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Guatemala: widespread violent repression against workers |
|
February 2008, ITUC
A new ITUC report on core labour standards in Guatemala issued to coincide with the trade policy review at the WTO demonstrates how trade unionists are being discriminated against, threatened and even murdered as a result of their trade union activities.
The ITUC report particularly condemns the failure of the Guatemalan government to ensure that the murders of trade unionists are investigated and prosecuted. 'The killings, the death threats and the harassment must be stopped immediately,' stated Guy Ryder, ITUC general secretary. 'The continuous violent repression of workers' right to form and join trade unions shows that the government is failing to implement the ILO Conventions it has ratified and that trade unionists do not have the liberty to carry out their union tasks without risking their lives.'
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Unemployment Rises in World's 'Banana Capital' |
February 2009, Bananalink
Unemployment figures have more than doubled in Machala, Ecuador over the last year. The city known as the “world's
banana capital” had an unemployment rate of 3.5% in 2007. According to latest survey this figure has soared to more
than 8.7%.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Costa Rican Unions issue Alert over proposed Labour Reform |
|
February 2009, Bananalink
Unions and media from Costa Rica are concerned about the new “Social and Economic Plan” presented by President Oscar Arias' government to mitigate the impact of the financial crisis.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Go Bananas this Fairtrade Fortnight |
|
February 2009, Fairtrade Foundation
Eat a Fairtrade banana and be part of the world's biggest banana event. The Fairtrade Foundation are celebrating the success of Fairtrade bananas in the UK where one in every four bananas sold is Fairtrade certified with plans to make this 50% by 2012.
Read more...
|
|
|
27 January 2009, Action Aid
Moves last week by Asda and Morrisons to slash the price of bananas were branded shockingly irresponsible by development charities today. They say the price cuts are a serious setback in the ongoing battle to improve the appallingly poor conditions endured by plantation workers in the developing world. Campaigners fear that other supermarkets will follow suit and slash prices.
Read more...
Read a response to Banana Link concerns about the banana price wars from Asda boss Andy Bond.
|
|
|
Continued appeal for help in Costa Rican disasters...Earthquake strikes in flood region |
|
14 January 2009

Last Thursday an earthquake hit the Sarapaqui banana producing region of Costa Rica which only last month was devastated by flooding leaving thousands homeless and without jobs. Local media report at least 40 dead and over 500 houses destroyed by the earthquake, although our union partners fear the death toll is higher with many more yet to be accounted for since the earthquake struck.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Protecting Migrant Workers from the Fallout of the Economic Crisis |
|
18 December, ITUC
“The international trade union movement is keeping a close watch on the responses to the economic and financial crisis to ensure that they are not at the expense of the fundamental rights of migrant workers,” warned Guy Ryder, general secretary of the ITUC. At a time of massive job losses, migrant workers, often confined to the most precarious and least protected jobs, are in the front line of the economic and financial crisis. Their families in their countries of origin could also be badly affected, as they often depend heavily for their survival on money sent home by the migrant workers.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
New Report Shows the Cost of the Global Pineapple Industry to Workers and Communities |
|
15 December 2008, International Labor Rights Forum
A new report by the International Labor Rights Forum (ILRF) shows how global food corporations fail to respect human rights, public health and the environment in their supply chains. The report demonstrates how pineapple workers and their communities in two of the largest pineapple producing nations, Costa Rica and the Philippines, have not enjoyed the benefits of the expanding profits from the pineapple export sector. Trade benefits awarded to these countries have not improved labor or environmental conditions, though Dole is currently petitioning the U.S. Trade Representative for further tariff reductions on its pineapple products.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
International report exposes 5 worst companies for freedom of association |
|
15 December 2008, International Labor Rights Forum
A new report published by the International Labor Rights Forum (ILRF), to mark International Human Rights Day, has highlighted corporations known for violating workers’ freedom of association and right to organize. Selected on the basis of their ties to violence against trade unions and suppression of the universal right to organise, this year’s top offenders include three of the main actors along the international tropical fruit supply chain - Dole, Del Monte and Wal-Mart.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Urgent appeal to help victims of Costa Rica flooding |
|
December 2008
T orrential rains have destroyed banana plantations in the Caribbean coastal regions of Costa Rica. It is estimated that up to 10,000 hectares have been affected which could lead to the loss of 10,000 jobs in the banana export industry. At least 46,000 people have been rendered homeless with damage running into tens of millions of US dollars. A state of emergency has been declared in the Limon and Sarapiqui regions.
Flooding in Sixaola, Costa Rica
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Every worker counts: justice for workers employed by companies operating in Tesco's UK supply chain |
2 December 2008, UNITE press release
Unite, Britain's biggest union, last week launched national demonstrations outside Tesco stores to alert customers to the union's concerns about the treatment of workers employed by companies in the UK supply chain that produces meat for Tesco stores. Launched by Unite's Joint General Secretary, Tony Woodley, a national photo call illustrated with giant chickens was held outside Tesco in Regent Street. Unite's message to Tesco is that: "Every Worker Counts". The demonstrations mark the beginning of an ongoing campaign, calling for justice for workers employed by companies operating in Tesco's UK meat supply chain.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Banana Plantations Frequently the Location for Anti-Union Repression on the American Continent |
1 December 2008, ITUC
The situation facing trade unions on the American continent is nothing other than dramatic. That was the main message of the 'Americas' section of the ITUC Annual Survey on Violations of Trade Union Rights, which was published today. This part of the world predictably retained its infamous reputation as the most dangerous continent for trade unionists, largely owing to Colombia, where 39 trade unionists lost their lives as a result of their union activities.
Read more...
|
|
|
WTO Underlines EU Banana Decision |
|
27 November 2008, www.freshplaza.com
An appeal by the EU has fallen through after the WTO confirmed that the bloc's banana import policies were inconsistent with global trade rules
The World Trade Organisation (WTO) has this week ruled that the European Union's import tariffs for bananas break global commerce rules, dismissing an appeal by the bloc. The decision confirms the verdict reached by the WTO's dispute settlement panel in April, which ruled that duties should be brought in line with global trade agreements, following complaints by Ecuador and the US that current tariffs unfairly favoured African-Caribbean-Pacific (ACP) countries.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Banana Producers Demand Reference Price Rise |
|
24 November 2008, www.reefertrends.com
Costa Rica's independent banana producers are asking the Government to impose a 19% increase to cover the rise in production costs. The current reference price of US$7.17 per box is due for revision on 1 January 2009 – the independent producers, who account for 16K hectares of the total estimated 40K hectares of banana production in Costa Rica, are asking that the price paid to them by the exporters should rise to US$8.50 per box. The reasons behind the demand include a rise in the cost of controlling Black Sigatoka, increased packaging and fertilizer costs. Only three months ago the reference price was increased from US$6.45 per box to account for an increase in production costs.
|
|
|
Ethiopia Plans to Export Bananas |
|
16 November 2008, www.reefertrends.com
Ethiopia currently produces an estimated 200K MT of bananas per year, all of which is destined for domestic consumption. Efforts are underway to enable Ethiopia supply banana to the world market for the first time, according to an Ethiopian investor engaged in banana cultivation. In an interview published with the Ethiopian News Agency ENA the investor, Gebrekerstos Gad claimed that his company was undertaking various activities to improve the quality of banana in preparation for an export push. “We already have started quality improving activities through the application of tissue culture, [agricultural practice used to propagate plants under germ-free conditions] to get our own quality banana varieties,” he said. He claimed his company has had similar experiences in the Cameroon and that it plans to start exporting bananas next year.
|
|
|
ACP expresses serious concerns on latest developments on bananas |
15 November 2008, ACP press statement
The banana companies in African, Caribbean and Pacific (ACP) States maybe forced out of business following the European Union’s decision to negotiate a Free Trade agreement (FTA) with Central American countries in what the ACP Group describes as on “too generous” terms. The ACP Group expressed shock that only a week after the EU signed the first Economic Partnership Agreement (EPA) with an ACP region (CARIFORUM), which supposes to secure, and expand preferential access for ACP bananas into the EU market, the EU has gone ahead to negotiate an FTA with the Central Americans in terms which pose serious threat to ACP preferences.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
EU to Propose Tariff Reduction to Central Americans |
|
13 November 2008
The Costa Rican press has reported that Brussels will make a new proposal for reducing the EU banana tariff, following the demise of the 'peace agreement' brokered by WTO Director-general Pascal Lamy in Geneva in late July. It is understood that the offer will be made in the framework of the EU-Central America Association Agreement negotiations currently at their half-way point. If accepted, the proposal would see an initla fall from 176 euros/tonne to 148 euros on 1st January 2009, then a gradual step-by-step reduction to 95 euros over a period of ten years.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Conference on Latin America 2008 |
|
The Latin America 2008 conference Making a Better World Possible will be taking place in London on 6th December. The event brings together trade unionists, NGOs, academics and progressive movements from Latin America and the UK to explore recent developments across the region.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Costa Rican unions lodge complaint with EU |
|
4th November, San José
Trade unions from both private and public sector in Costa Rica have lodged a formal complaint against their government, alleging serious and systematic violations of core international labour standards. The complaint is directed to the European Commission which, since January 2006, grants trade preferences on a wide range of products as part of its Generalised System of Preferences "Plus" scheme.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Jamaica: Banana workers demand land |
|
3rd November, Radiojamaica.com
Scores of workers who are to be made redundant at the Eastern Banana Estates in St. Thomas are asking to take over ownership of the land they had worked. The workers are among a group of 500 who assembled on Friday morning to receive their redundancy payments. The Estate closed down after it was destroyed by Tropical Storm Gustav in August of this year.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Jamaica's banana future looks bleak |
|
4 November 2008, jamaica-gleaner.com
Prime Minister Bruce Golding painted a bleak picture of the future of the banana industry last Tuesday, during a sitting of the House of Representatives. "What we need to do is to move with the land resources we have, the infrastructure that is there to see how we can diversify," Golding told the House. Already, the chief producers of banana for export have pulled out of production. The straw that broke the camel's back was Tropical Storm Gustav, which destroyed a vast percentage of banana crops in eastern Jamaica.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Floods affect Honduran banana communities |
30th October, La Lima and Colon, Northern Honduras
On the tenth anniversary of the most devastating Hurricane to hit Central America in decades, over a thousand banana workers have lost their homes as result of serious flooding in the banana zones of Northern Honduras. The death toll was reported to have reached 18 last week, as people were trapped by rivers rising after torrential rains.
|
|
Read more...
|
|
|
Corbana tackles labour issues |
29 October 2008
Costa Rican industry body Corbana has held a first meeting with trade unions
representing workers in the banana sector, breaking years of impasse over labour
issues. The new Corbana Working Commission on labour standards will meet regularly
to tackle issues of concern to plantation workers. It parallels the work done on
environmental issues by the Comision Ambiental Bananera, which has led to tangible
improvements in the environmental impacts of the industry since its formation in the
1990s. The new Commission results directly from commitments made by industry and trade
unions at a Round Table on Labour Standards in San José in May.
|
|
|
Voters approve new Ecuadorian constitution |
|
27 October 2008
Voters overwhelmingly approved a new constitution on Sunday 28th September that amongst other things ended labour sub-contracting in all sectors of the economy in Ecuador and heralded other important reforms to labour law.
The new constitution also includes reference to the idea of food sovereignty - a
world first. Despite constant predictions of a close vote, nearly 64% of the voters
approved and only 29% were against.
|
|
Read more...
|
|